There exist two distinct perspectives concerning the process of artists securing record deals within the music industry. This Insight article aims to delve into the psychological aspects that underlie the requirements for achieving success in this endeavor. Moreover, we aspire to equip musicians with the necessary tools and guidance to bypass the competitive race and approach the industry from a position of stability rather than desperation.

• The first perspective pertains to exceptional cases, exemplified by individuals such as Ed Sheeran, who possess not only talent but also the right age, style, messaging, and marketability.

• The second perspective applies to the majority, who fail to meet the crucial criteria that hold the greatest significance for industry professionals. The term “music business” itself reflects the reasoning behind this classification. Analogous to the earlier days of Silicon Valley, where investment bankers would invest in 50 startups to discover a single exceptional venture, the music industry functions in a similar manner. These are the groups of artists that record labels generally sign, grouping them into a portfolio that comprises acts that are less extraordinary and generate comparatively smaller percentages of revenue for the label through sheer bulk, instead of individuality. This reality can be challenging for performers, bands, and musicians to accept.

Musicians, like their counterparts in other artistic domains, frequently encounter rejection and criticism for various reasons.

That is a tough pill for performers, bands or musicians to swallow.

Musicians, like any other artists, often face rejection and criticism for a variety of reasons.

ULTIMATELY, MUSICIANS SHOULD FOCUS ON THEIR PASSIONS, STAY TRUE TO THEIR ARTISTIC VISION, AND FIND THEIR OWN AUDIENCE WHO APPRECIATES AND CONNECTS WITH THEIR MUSIC. THAT ALSO DOES NOT MEAN BECOMING A MARTYR TO SOME UNSEEN THEOLOGICAL PURPOSE OR CAUSE.

Here are a few common reasons why musicians encounter rejection and criticism:

Subjectivity of Taste: Music is highly subjective, and different people have diverse preferences and tastes. What one person may love, another might dislike. Musicians have to understand that not everyone will appreciate or connect with their style, genre, or artistic choices. This subjectivity can result in rejection or criticism from certain individuals or audiences. You must learn to never use this criticism as a measurement of your own identity, but a symbol of the price you may have to be willing to pay versus selling out to a perceived existential crises or perceived moral violation.

Competition: The music industry can be highly competitive, with numerous talented artists vying for attention and success. In such a competitive landscape, rejection is an inevitable part of the journey.

Musicians may face rejection in the form of failed auditions, rejected demo tapes, or not being selected for opportunities like record deals or festival performances. The competitive nature of the industry makes it necessary to develop resilience and perseverance in the face of rejection.

Artistic Growth: Constructive criticism plays a vital role in an artist’s growth. Musicians often seek feedback from industry professionals, fellow musicians, or even their audience to improve their craft. However, not all criticism will be constructive or helpful. Some criticism may be harsh or unfair, targeting personal aspects rather than focusing on the music itself.

Musicians must learn to differentiate between constructive feedback that can help them grow and unfounded criticism that may be disregarded.

Evolving Trends and Expectations:  Musical trends and audience expectations change over time. What may be popular today might not be as well-received in the future.

Musicians who are innovative or experimental may face criticism or rejection because their work challenges established norms or fails to align with current trends. However, it’s important for musicians to stay true to their artistic vision and create music that resonates with them, even if it means facing rejection or criticism.

Art as Vulnerability: Music is often deeply personal and reflective of the artist’s emotions, experiences, and perspectives. Sharing such personal expressions with the world requires vulnerability. Unfortunately, this vulnerability can make musicians more susceptible to criticism and rejection, as their work becomes open to interpretation and subjective judgment. It’s important for musicians to develop a strong sense of self and resilience to navigate these challenges.

It’s critically important, even crucial for musicians to remember that rejection and criticism are part of the creative journey. It’s impossible to please everyone, and embracing feedback and learning from it can lead to personal growth and artistic development. Talent is only a part of the equation when pursuing a rewarding career in the arts.

If you enjoy this Insight article, you have the option to subscribe to our monthly band Insights newsletter where we explore everything Music Industry Related, by joining Songtracks here.

 ©2023 by Michael Wright